Use Scite to Check Whether a Citation Supports Your Claim
When a report cites a study for a specific claim, open Scite for the study's DOI and read how later papers cite it. Follow the relevant statements back to the original results before deciding what your report can say.
Worked example
Illustrative claim and scope correction
Draft claim = Daily written handoffs reduce delivery delays for all remote teams. Original result = Six project teams that adopted daily handoffs reported fewer unanswered questions in the next four weeks than in the prior four weeks. Relevant citing passage = Discusses communication habits and records no delivery outcome. Revision = In six project teams, daily written handoffs were associated with fewer unanswered questions over four weeks. Evidence to look for next = A study that measures delivery delays.
Steps
- Write the claim in one sentence and record its population, outcome and time span. Search Scite for the exact title or DOI and check that the record matches your source.
- Open Smart Citations and read a supporting, contrasting or mentioning statement where relevant. Record the claim each passage actually discusses and which part of the citing paper it comes from.
- Read the original paper's methods and results for the same outcome. Verify the study design, population and comparison before using it for a causal claim.
- Narrow your wording when your source supports a smaller claim. Save the DOI and the supporting passage or table location next to your revised sentence.
What to check
- Confirm the passage refers to the right paper when several references appear in one sentence.
- Read both sides when citing studies report conflicting results. Differences in population, outcome or study design can explain part of the disagreement.
- Review the actual outcome wording even when the citation shows a supporting classification.