Compare Cline and Continue With the Same VS Code Planning Task
Cline and Continue both document planning modes. A short planning task gives a concrete comparison of the context they pick up, the tools they request, and the quality of the plan on your codebase.
Worked example
Comparison prompt and three-file fixture
threshold.js: export const minimumSeats = 4; threshold.test.js: assert.equal(minimumSeats, 4); theme.js: export const compactLayoutWidth = 4; Prompt: Plan a change from a minimum of four seats to six. Identify the files and tests involved. Explain why the layout setting is unrelated. Leave all files unchanged.
Steps
- Create a throwaway project with the three filenames in the fixture. Use simple files with one threshold, one test asserting it, and a separate unrelated display setting.
- Open separate clean VS Code sessions or profiles. Use Cline Plan mode and Continue Plan mode. Give both the same prompt and, if possible, choose the same provider and model version.
- Score whether each plan found the implementation and test, excluded the unrelated setting, and refrained from editing. Compare confirmations and review ergonomics before moving to implementation.
What to check
- Changing model or available context between extensions can explain a result. Record those differences beside your observations.
- This exercise compares how the tools support a planning workflow. It cannot measure code quality until you review a separate implementation.