How to Test an AI UI Design Tool on a Form With Errors
A polished form mockup can still leave users stranded after an error. Compare tools on the complete interaction, using the same instructions and a small set of realistic inputs.
Worked example
Synthetic two-field form test
Brief: Request a demo with required name and email. Submit Dee and dee.example. Expected error: “Enter an email address in the form [email protected].” Correct to [email protected]. The name stays filled and the confirmation appears.
Steps
- Ask each tool for the same default, invalid and successful states. Include explicit fields and labels in the brief.
- In a runnable prototype, use the keyboard to enter the sample values, submit and correct the error. In a static design, document the expected focus and recovery sequence for implementation.
- Score which states are present and how easy they are to edit. Check that an error description and accepted correction both remain visible.
What to check
- Identify labels without relying on placeholder text.
- Ensure the user can find the error and recover with a keyboard.